Every year I hear countless complaints about the bad theology of many Christmas carols. It is true, many of them do relay information not even dreamed of in the Gospels of Luke or Matthew. However, this week I have been reflecting on just how important, bad theology and all, our Christmas carols are for retelling the story of ‘God with us’ at Christmas. In a world that is Jesus saturated and biblically illiterate (as BW3 would say) the Christian carols are probably the greatest witness we have to the incarnation. Year after year people of all persuasions and beliefs belt out these tunes with no idea what they are singing. Nevertheless the gospel is preached; albeit it subtly.
In light of my musings this past week I am curious to find out what people’s favourite Christmas carols are. I am a big fan of ‘Silent Night’ (Speaking of bad theology) & ‘Come all ye faithful’. However, it is the old English hymn ‘The First Noël’ that captures my heart and mind year after year. When sung well it evokes in me faith and appreciation for all Christ has done. Furthermore, as I read through the words I find very little to disagree with. The two Gospel birth narratives are retold poetically and simply.
So, what are your favourite Christmas carols?
the archives near Emmaus 
Light of the World by Matt Redman. Sang it as the Communion hymn at Church 2 weeks ago. This is Chris Tomlin’s version:
I like Silent Night as well. I imagine that even though it was likely not a “silent night” that there is a sense in which we can imagine time standing still, reflection occurring, and Mary and Joseph being in awe of this child that would cause the world so much trouble while being its Saviour.
My favorite is “Happy Christmas (War is Over)” by John Lennon. John’s grasp of the importance of Jesus bringing peace was pivotal to….ah, I can’t do it. I’m getting nauseous thinking about that 😉 (Lennon’s social awareness was more spot on than many in the “religious right” but his quasi-Christianity is repulsive).
Seriously, my favorite is “O Holy Night,” specifically the line “and the soul felt its worth.” Having “God with us” is an honor beyond words. The atoning sacrifice of Jesus is God’s statement of love for us (Rom. 8:32), but this song reminds me that Jesus’ mere presence is an honor.
Mary’s boy child
Mary did you know
mmm I’m sensing a theme here.
I have always found myself drawn to “O Holy Night.” Part of it is the tune and structure of the song (build up and break down). The other part is that I find it to be biblical enough.
I think Bitsy likes Mary. 🙂
Gerard,
I have that album and enjoy just about every song on it. Good choice!